HomeRRSP meltdown: which drawdown strategy wins?

RRSP meltdown

RRSP meltdown: which drawdown strategy wins?

Empty the RRSP early, take only the minimum, or fill a tax bracket? Compare all three over your full retirement on lifetime tax, OAS clawback, and what's left for your estate.

After 71, your RRSP must convert to a RRIF with mandatory minimum withdrawals — and a large RRIF can push you into the OAS clawback. The order you draw down accounts (RRSP vs TFSA vs non-registered) changes how much tax you pay over your lifetime and how much is left at the end. This simulator runs three strategies side by side over your full horizon.

After-tax dollars you want each year.

After inflation, e.g. 3.

RRSP first

Fund spending from the RRSP before touching TFSA or non-registered.

Lifetime tax$200,316
Total OAS clawback$0
Ending estate$211,165
Ending RRSP (pre-tax)$0

Minimum RRIF · Lowest lifetime tax

Withdraw only the mandatory RRIF minimum; spend TFSA first.

Lifetime tax$184,598
Total OAS clawback$0
Ending estate$315,996
Ending RRSP (pre-tax)$315,996

Bracket fill

Draw the RRSP up to a tax-bracket ceiling each year, banking the rest.

Lifetime tax$212,127
Total OAS clawback$0
Ending estate$144,178
Ending RRSP (pre-tax)$0
RRSP / RRIF balance over time
Show the data table
RRSP/RRIF balance by age for each drawdown strategy.
AgeRRSP firstMinimum RRIFBracket fill
65$674,581$721,000$643,126
70$535,577$835,837$332,114
75$374,434$728,690$0
80$187,625$607,456$0
85$0$470,385$0
90$0$315,996$0

Scenario projection for education, not advice. Modelled on 2026 federal and provincial rates with a flat real return; non-registered withdrawals are treated as return of capital and the ending estate is shown pre-tax. Real results depend on markets, timing, and your full situation.

What's next

What's your after-tax retirement income?Net income by source — TFSA, RRIF, CPP, OAS.Will your OAS be clawed back?The recovery tax — and how to keep more.Do you qualify for the GIS?The tax-free top-up and its income ceiling.